Cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Extrude problem

Solution Partner Genius Solution Partner Genius
Solution Partner Genius

Hello all!

 

I am trying to extrude a surface upto 10 mm (with draft) , but for some weird reson, the actual extrude is somewhere around 7.

 

I can consider NX doing trigonometric calculations for the draft angle, but unfortunately, I tried this in some other cases and it does the job as expected.

 

Check the images below.

3.JPG

 

1.JPG

 

2.JPG

 

Paras Raina
Sr. Application Engineer | Solid Edge ST10 | NX 11
MSC Systems Pvt. Ltd. (India)
7 REPLIES

Re: Extrude problem

Pioneer
Pioneer

Hello Paras

 

the draft angle has no influence on the extrude limit, have you tried without draft and what is the outcome there?

 

Greetings

 

mArco

_____________________________
Are you familiar with my product?
click here

Re: Extrude problem

Solution Partner Genius Solution Partner Genius
Solution Partner Genius

I indeed did, but surprisingly, output is exactly 10 mm in that.

And just a thing that I noticed here:

Angle was 30 degrees, extrusion was 10 mm.

10 cos(30) = 8.66

 

Any reasons for this?

Paras Raina
Sr. Application Engineer | Solid Edge ST10 | NX 11
MSC Systems Pvt. Ltd. (India)

Re: Extrude problem

Pioneer
Pioneer

 

Since you are using a fixed vector for the extrusion direction I would have guessed that this is the reason, but judging from your screencapture this is not the case. Also the "until extended" option is not enabled here..

 

What happens when you pull the length vector in realtime, does it stop/snap at a certain level?

 

(view in My Videos)

_____________________________
Are you familiar with my product?
click here

Re: Extrude problem

Legend
Legend
If you used "Sheet Edge" or "Face Edge" for Curve Rule to create Extrude Feature (rather then "Tangent Curve"),
you can get the unusual result.

Because NX use different mechanisim to create the 'side faces' and 'end cap faces'.
In this case, the End cap face is created by translation (10mm).
And side face is create by extruding until the endcap face (with draft angle) .

 Sunkap Ahn, Senior Support Engineer


logo

Re: Extrude problem

Siemens Phenom Siemens Phenom
Siemens Phenom

Hi,

 

When you extrude a sheet then the sheet is translated and the side walls are calculated from the egdes separately (including the draft) and then a body is produced.

See example below.

(view in My Videos)

 

Regards, **bleep**

Re: Extrude problem

Solution Partner Genius Solution Partner Genius
Solution Partner Genius

Hi @DickBaardse

 

Thanks for taking out the time to explain this.

 

Actually, I had two other 'conditions' when the draft didn't really change the length along the vector.

 

Video below shows the first case when Draft changes the length with the change in angle. The second change in the video (on the third body) shows no change in length with the Draft angle change.

 

PS. The parent features are different for all three (for first one, extrude is created from an edge of swept surface, while in the 'third' one, its from a fill surface. For second body, extrude is done on 'extended sheet' edge. I don't think this should make any difference.

Also, notice that the angle values are positive & negative in the first & second cases respectively.

 

(view in My Videos)

 

@SKAHNAll three extrudes are done with curve rule set to tangent curves.

 

@mascaritasChange in extrude length (along the vector) maintains the angle of the draft for all three cases as it's supposed to.

Paras Raina
Sr. Application Engineer | Solid Edge ST10 | NX 11
MSC Systems Pvt. Ltd. (India)

Re: Extrude problem

Solution Partner Genius Solution Partner Genius
Solution Partner Genius

@DickBaardseI have re-uploaded the video (earlier one wasn't running due to incorrect format).

Paras Raina
Sr. Application Engineer | Solid Edge ST10 | NX 11
MSC Systems Pvt. Ltd. (India)