Cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

ER 7851802 - Bend lines with angle information

Genius
Genius

Good day everyone, with this topic I would like to see if we are the only one with this reqeust. Also if possible I would like to gather as much support from the community as I can get ofcource. This case is 1 out of 2 of our biggest wishes in our wishlist in Solid Edge.

 1 Gpi logo.png

 

Company: GPI

Website: www.gpi.nl

 

System:

Windows 10 Professional

Solid EdgeST8 – MP12

 

Solid Edge seats:

GPI – Division Netherlands:  11 Seats.

GPI – Division Poland:  5 Seats.

 

Our product contains an 100% custom made dynamic environment in Solid Edge.

 

2 Gpi uitleg.PNG

Problem case

For this problem I took an project that was easy to compare. These two projects have the most resemblances with each other, to have the best case with improving lofted flange.

 

Solid Edge:

3 Solid edge tekening.png

 

 

Autocad:

4 Autocad tekening.png

 

Solid Edge: Lofted flange flatten with bend table.

5 Solid edge bend table.png

Autocad: Produced cone from an lisp that gave the bending line and angle.

6 Autocad bend uitslag.PNG

 

The lisp has been made approx 15years ago, and till today SE doesn't provide any information about bending lines within the lofted flange.

 

I have tested it in ST10, and because of that I now would like some opinions from the community.

Sander
The Netherlands
--------------------------------------------------
i7-7700K CPU @ 4.20 GHz / Quadro P4000
Solid Edge ST10 MP7 / Windows 10 Pro - Build 1803
5 REPLIES

Re: ER 7851802 - Bend lines with angle information

Phenom
Phenom

Hi Edgers,

 

Just wondering would anyone help me to find the way how to add the bendline angles to the flat drawing ?

 

as @Sander-NL mentioned, the bend table tells only about 2 sequences (1 and 2 one the drawing ).

 

Thank you

 

bend lines angle.png

 


Production: SE ST10 MP8
;

Re: ER 7851802 - Bend lines with angle information

Pioneer
Pioneer

Will this callout work? Capture.JPG

Re: ER 7851802 - Bend lines with angle information

Phenom
Phenom

Hi @Milro

 

Fantastic job.

 

I've forgotten about it - nice Trick !!

 

Thank you,

 

Arek


Production: SE ST10 MP8
;

Re: ER 7851802 - Bend lines with angle information

Genius
Genius

@Milro

 

The only thing is that practical 4 times 22degr is wrong with bends from square to round. Man Wink.

Sander
The Netherlands
--------------------------------------------------
i7-7700K CPU @ 4.20 GHz / Quadro P4000
Solid Edge ST10 MP7 / Windows 10 Pro - Build 1803

Re: ER 7851802 - Bend lines with angle information

Pioneer
Pioneer

You are right , I don't do a lot of completely square to round  mostly round to round .Sometimes flat to round 

which will give me a Lofted Flange : No Data error do to the fact that the angle will change 

from one end of the bend to the other . I agree that it would be nice to have a more robust solution

to lofted flange bend info.